International System of Trade Secrets Protection

Trade secrets constitute a vital component of intellectual property (IP), playing a critical role in fostering innovation and securing competitive advantages in global markets. Unlike patents, trademarks, and copyrights, which require formal registration, trade secrets derive their value from being confidential and undisclosed to competitors. The protection of trade secrets has gained increasing prominence with the rise of knowledge-based economies and the growing importance of information as a strategic business asset. However, the legal framework governing trade secret protection varies significantly across jurisdictions, creating challenges for multinational businesses operating in diverse regulatory environments.

This article examines the international framework for trade secret protection, focusing on key agreements and legislative instruments that govern this domain. It explores the legal challenges and enforcement mechanisms available globally, highlighting key developments and best practices for businesses to secure their trade secrets in a rapidly evolving international market.

What are Trade Secrets?

A trade secret refers to any confidential business information that provides a company with a competitive edge. Trade secrets include:

• Technical information – such as formulas, manufacturing processes, designs, and prototypes.
• Commercial information – including business strategies, pricing information, supplier and customer lists, and marketing data.
• Operational know-how – such as proprietary software, algorithms, and internal operational methods.

For information to qualify as a trade secret, it must meet three key criteria:

1. Secrecy – The information must not be generally known or accessible to others who could benefit from its disclosure.
2. Value – The information must have commercial value by its secrecy.
3. Reasonable Measures of Protection – The holder of the information must take reasonable steps to protect its secrecy.

Importance of Trade Secret Protection

Trade secrets are essential for businesses due to several reasons:

• They provide a competitive edge in the market by protecting proprietary knowledge.
• Unlike patents, trade secret protection does not require public disclosure, allowing companies to keep their competitive advantage secret.
• Trade secrets have no expiration period as long as they remain confidential.
• Trade secret protection reduces the risk of intellectual property theft and industrial espionage.

International Framework for Trade Secrets Protection

1. Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) Agreement

The most significant international framework for trade secret protection is the TRIPS Agreement (1994) administered by the World Trade Organization (WTO). The TRIPS Agreement established minimum standards for trade secret protection among member countries.

Key Provisions under TRIPS

• Article 39 of the TRIPS Agreement mandates the protection of undisclosed information.
• Member states are required to ensure that natural and legal persons have the means to prevent information lawfully under their control from being disclosed or used by others without consent, in a manner contrary to honest commercial practices.

Protection applies to information that:

• Is secret (not generally known).
• Has commercial value because of its secrecy.
• Has been subject to reasonable steps to maintain its secrecy.

TRIPS provides a framework but allows flexibility for member states to implement trade secret protection within their domestic laws.

2. World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO)

WIPO plays a key role in coordinating international efforts on trade secret protection.

• WIPO’s guidance on trade secrets highlights the importance of secrecy, commercial value, and reasonable measures to protect trade secrets.
• WIPO’s Trade Secrets Strategy emphasizes cross-border cooperation, enforcement, and capacity building to strengthen trade secret protection.
• WIPO promotes dispute resolution through its Arbitration and Mediation Center, which allows businesses to settle trade secret disputes outside of traditional litigation.

3. European Union (EU) Trade Secret Directive (2016/943)

The Directive on the Protection of Undisclosed Know-How and Business Information (2016/943) harmonized trade secret protection across EU member states.

Key Provisions

• Defines trade secrets in line with TRIPS criteria.
• Provides remedies for unlawful acquisition, use, and disclosure of trade secrets.
• Introduces protective measures during litigation to prevent further disclosure of trade secrets.
• Allows for compensation for damages caused by misappropriation.

The Directive has strengthened trade secret protection within the EU, ensuring consistency in enforcement and protection mechanisms across member states.

4. United States – Defend Trade Secrets Act (2016)

The United States passed the Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) in 2016, which provided a federal framework for the protection of trade secrets.

Key Provisions

• Allows trade secret owners to file civil lawsuits in federal court for misappropriation.
• Provides for seizure orders to prevent the dissemination of trade secrets.
• Allows for damages, injunctions, and legal fees to be recovered in case of misappropriation.
• Strengthens whistleblower protections to ensure fair enforcement of trade secret laws.

5. Japan – Unfair Competition Prevention Act

Japan’s trade secret protection is governed by the Unfair Competition Prevention Act (1993).

• The Act defines trade secrets and provides civil and criminal remedies for misappropriation.
• Strong penalties, including imprisonment and fines, are imposed for trade secret theft.
• Japan emphasizes enforcement measures through both administrative and judicial mechanisms.

6. China – Anti-Unfair Competition Law (1993, Amended 2019)

China’s trade secret protection falls under the Anti-Unfair Competition Law and related amendments.

• The 2019 amendment increased penalties for trade secret misappropriation.
• Enhanced protection for foreign enterprises operating in China.
• Broader scope for enforcement and stronger remedies for trade secret violations.

7. India – Trade Secrets Protection under Common Law

India does not have a specific statute governing trade secret protection. However, protection is provided through:

• Contract law – Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), confidentiality clauses, and employment contracts.
• Equity law – Courts protect trade secrets under the doctrine of breach of confidence.
• Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) – Provides penalties for theft of proprietary information under general criminal provisions.

Challenges in International Trade Secret Protection

Variability in National Laws – While TRIPS sets minimum standards, implementation differs across jurisdictions, creating inconsistencies in enforcement.

Cross-Border Enforcement Issues – Trade secret misappropriation often involves actors in different countries, making enforcement complex.

Cybersecurity Risks – The rise of digital technologies has increased the risk of trade secret theft through hacking and cyberattacks.

Limited Protection for Whistleblowers – Ensuring that whistleblower protections align with trade secret protection remains a challenge.

References

[1] Katherine Linton, The Importance of Trade Secrets: New Directions in International Trade Policy Making and Empirical Research, Available Here

[2] Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), Available Here

[3] Directive (EU) 2016/943 of the European Parliament and the Council, Available Here

[4] Unfair Competition Prevention Act, Available Here

Important Link

Law Library: Notes and Study Material for LLB, LLM, Judiciary, and Entrance Exams