Psychological Profiling of Suspects and Witnesses

What is Psychological Profiling?

Psychological profiling, or criminal profiling, involves the systematic study of behavioural evidence to predict an individual’s characteristics and personality traits. Profiling attempts to bridge the gap between the crime scene and the criminal's psychological state by examining aspects like motive, risk factors, and potential behaviour patterns. This method is particularly useful for identifying suspects in cases involving serial offences, complex crimes, or instances where conventional evidence is lacking.

Legal Framework for Psychological Profiling in India

In India, psychological profiling falls within the broader scope of forensic psychology and criminology, both of which are gaining recognition under the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, and related statutes.

Although Indian law does not specifically codify psychological profiling, certain forensic practices, such as narco-analysis, polygraph tests, and brain-mapping, indirectly involve profiling methods.

Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023: This Act provides for the admissibility of expert testimony, including forensic psychological analysis. It permits expert opinions to be admitted as evidence, opening the door for profiling techniques to be used as supplementary insights.

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023:  The BNSS grants investigative powers for criminal probes, indirectly allowing forensic profiling in specific scenarios. Profiling is especially used in high-profile or serial crimes where other investigative techniques may be limited.

Constitutional Safeguards: Articles 20(3) and 21 of the Indian Constitution protect individuals against self-incrimination and preserve the right to personal liberty. These protections impact the application of certain profiling techniques, such as narco-analysis or polygraph tests, which must not infringe upon these fundamental rights.

Psychological Profiling Techniques and Their Application

The primary methods used in psychological profiling include criminal personality profiling, behavioural profiling, and geographic profiling. In India, these techniques are applied selectively in high-profile cases and in instances where traditional investigation techniques are insufficient.

1. Criminal Personality Profiling: This technique focuses on understanding the psychological characteristics of a suspect based on past behaviour, motives, and socio-psychological factors. Profiling experts analyze factors like aggression, narcissism, and antisocial traits.

2. Behavioural Profiling: This involves analyzing behavioural evidence left at crime scenes, such as patterns in the method of committing the crime, choice of location, and time of offence. Behavioural profiling has been applied in cases involving serial murders and terrorism.

3. Geographic Profiling: Primarily used in serial offences, geographic profiling examines the spatial patterns of crimes to predict the location of the suspect’s residence or operational base. In India, geographic profiling is limited but has been effectively applied in cases of organized crime.

Psychological Profiling of Witnesses

Witnesses play a crucial role in criminal investigations, and profiling helps ascertain their credibility. Witness profiling is particularly valuable in cases involving children or vulnerable individuals. Courts in India often rely on psychological assessments to evaluate the truthfulness and reliability of witnesses, especially in sensitive cases involving child abuse or sexual violence.

1. Evaluating Credibility: Profiling witnesses can reveal signs of deception, suggestibility, or manipulation, thereby aiding in establishing the reliability of testimonies.
2. Impact on Witness Protection: Witness profiling also serves as a tool for identifying potential threats to witnesses and providing them with the necessary protection. This aligns with the principles of the Witness Protection Scheme
   , 2018, under the Supreme Court's directives.

Case Studies and Judicial Precedents in India

Several landmark cases highlight the application and limitations of psychological profiling in the Indian legal context.

1. Selvi v. State of Karnataka (2010): This Supreme Court ruling dealt with the admissibility of narco-analysis, polygraph tests, and brain mapping. The court held that these methods if conducted without consent, violate an individual's right to privacy and personal liberty under Articles 20(3) and 21. However, the judgment permitted the voluntary use of such tests, setting a precedent for the limited use of profiling in investigations.

2. Nirbhaya Case (2012): In the aftermath of the brutal assault, forensic psychologists were called upon to profile the perpetrators’ psychological states. This case highlighted the role of psychological profiling in understanding the sociopathic tendencies of the accused and aided in forming arguments for severe sentencing.

The Role of Forensic Psychologists and Profilers

Forensic psychologists and profilers work closely with law enforcement agencies to support investigations. Their role includes assisting in suspect profiling, advising on witness credibility, and providing expert testimony in courts. The contributions of forensic psychologists are vital in cases where motive, mental state, and behavioural patterns significantly impact judicial decisions.

Psychological Profiling: Ethical and Legal Considerations

Psychological profiling raises ethical issues, particularly concerning privacy and the potential for misinterpretation. In India, the absence of explicit legal provisions on profiling calls for judicial oversight to prevent misuse.

• Ethical Concerns: Profiling methods can infringe upon an individual’s privacy rights and may lead to biases. For instance, racial and socio-economic biases can skew profiling conclusions, impacting justice delivery.
• Legal Safeguards: Courts have emphasized the need for voluntary consent in profiling methods like polygraphs and narco-analysis. Ensuring these methods align with constitutional protections is crucial to prevent potential rights violations.

Future of Psychological Profiling under Indian Law

The field of psychological profiling in India is evolving, with an increasing focus on training law enforcement in psychological assessment techniques. The establishment of forensic psychology departments and research centres also holds promise for advancing the field. However, there remains a need for legislative reform to clarify the permissible scope and methodologies of psychological profiling.

1. Training and Education: Establishing specialized programs in forensic psychology can enhance the quality of psychological profiling. Training programs in collaboration with foreign agencies could provide Indian law enforcement with the skills needed for effective profiling.
2. Legislative Reform: Given the expanding role of forensic psychology, there is a growing need to incorporate explicit provisions on profiling within the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023
    or create separate guidelines. This would provide courts with clearer guidelines on the admissibility and limitations of profiling.
   

Conclusion

Psychological profiling, though still developing in India, holds immense potential in criminal investigations and legal processes. By understanding the psychological dimensions of crime, law enforcement agencies can develop more effective investigative strategies and provide courts with insights that support judicial decision-making.

As forensic psychology gains prominence, legislative reforms and training initiatives will be crucial in realizing the full potential of psychological profiling. Balancing investigative needs with ethical and legal safeguards will be essential for profiling to become an integral part of India’s criminal justice system. 

References