Book Review: The First and Last Freedom | Jiddu Krishnamurti

Introduction

Jiddu Krishnamurti, one of the most profound thinkers of the 20th century, delves into human consciousness and the nature of freedom in his seminal work, The First and Last Freedom. Though originally published in 1954, the book continues to resonate with readers due to its deep exploration of human psychology, philosophy, and spirituality.

It is both timeless and radical, questioning traditional norms of thought and behaviour. Krishnamurti’s approach is unique, challenging readers to break free from conditioned patterns and embark on a journey of self-discovery, making this work especially relevant for those engaged in legal studies or practices where freedom and morality are frequently analyzed.

Core Themes and Insights

At the heart of The First and Last Freedom is Krishnamurti’s notion of freedom as an intrinsic, inner state rather than something achieved through external means. His discussions emphasize that true freedom cannot be attained through adherence to societal expectations, norms, or beliefs, which he sees as constraints on the mind.

Instead, Krishnamurti argues for the necessity of breaking away from conditioned thinking and discovering an authentic existence. This theme offers a unique perspective to legal scholars and practitioners, as it reframes the concept of freedom away from the socio-political construct and into the psychological domain.

Krishnamurti explores the limits of thought as a tool for achieving freedom. He argues that while thinking is instrumental for survival and understanding, it inherently imposes limitations. Thought, according to Krishnamurti, is a product of memory and the past.

Since legal systems are built upon precedents and historical foundations, his critique is particularly intriguing for readers in the legal field. He posits that thinking creates divisions, conflicts, and, ultimately, hinders true liberation, suggesting a re-evaluation of how legal practitioners might interpret freedom beyond the conventional framework of law and order.

Another significant theme Krishnamurti addresses is the concept of self-knowledge, which he describes as the pathway to freedom. By observing oneself without judgment or preconception, he believes individuals can uncover their true nature, free from the influence of societal conditioning. This introspective approach can be insightful for those in the legal profession, where ethical questions and dilemmas often arise.

The practice of self-awareness, as advocated by Krishnamurti, has the potential to inform ethical decision-making and enhance the clarity and impartiality required in legal practice.

Analysis and Relevance to Legal Studies

The text’s philosophical underpinnings present a critical look at how structures—be they social, political, or legal—can impede true understanding and freedom. Krishnamurti’s views challenge traditional approaches to governance and law, urging a departure from rigid doctrines and habitual thinking. For legal professionals, his ideas provoke thought about the role of the law in shaping society. While the law strives to maintain order,

Krishnamurti’s philosophy suggests that genuine freedom might only be achieved when individuals move beyond conventional definitions of morality and legality.

In particular, The First and Last Freedom encourages questioning the fixed beliefs and assumptions that underlie legal doctrines.

For instance, Krishnamurti’s assertion that true freedom is internal rather than externally granted may resonate in discussions on human rights, where debates often arise about the inherent versus legislated nature of freedoms. Law students and practitioners may find value in applying his ideas to contemporary legal debates, such as individual rights versus societal obligations, the balance between freedom and security, and the impact of legal systems on personal autonomy.

Additionally, Krishnamurti’s concept of authority—viewed as an obstacle to freedom—offers an intriguing angle for analyzing the dynamics of power within legal institutions. He emphasizes that reliance on external authority, whether religious, political, or social, stifles individuality and personal growth. For those in the legal profession, this perspective serves as a prompt to reflect on the role of authority in the justice system. It raises the question of whether absolute adherence to precedent and institutional hierarchy may inhibit innovative interpretations of the law and ethical judgments.

Structure and Style

Krishnamurti’s prose is both direct and introspective, employing a conversational style that engages readers in a dialogue. Rather than prescribing solutions, he leads readers on a self-inquisitive journey, encouraging them to look within themselves. The book’s structure, which comprises questions posed by audiences and Krishnamurti’s responses, provides a fluid, interactive format that mirrors the introspective process he advocates. This style makes The First and Last Freedom accessible and allows readers to approach each theme at their own pace, reflecting on the content deeply and personally.

For those accustomed to legal texts that follow a structured argument, Krishnamurti’s approach may feel unconventional. His refusal to provide definitive answers aligns with his philosophy of avoiding dogma and exploring a path of individual discovery. This fluid, non-linear style could inspire legal professionals to adopt more open-minded approaches when tackling complex issues, fostering a sense of empathy and openness to alternative perspectives.

Conclusion

The First and Last Freedom offers readers a profound journey into understanding the essence of freedom, challenging them to question deeply ingrained beliefs and societal structures. Krishnamurti’s work transcends conventional philosophical discourse, offering insights that are as relevant to personal growth as they are to broader societal constructs. For those in the legal field, his ideas provide a refreshing perspective on the concept of freedom, authority, and self-knowledge, inviting legal scholars and practitioners to reflect on the limitations and potential of the law.

While not a typical legal text, The First and Last Freedom holds immense value for anyone interested in exploring the philosophical dimensions of freedom and justice. Krishnamurti’s insights encourage readers to move beyond the surface of societal expectations and legal boundaries, fostering a holistic understanding of freedom as an internal, deeply personal state. For those willing to embrace his unconventional approach, the book offers a transformative reading experience that resonates well beyond the pages, potentially enriching one’s personal and professional journey.

Recommendation

In summary, The First and Last Freedom by Jiddu Krishnamurti is a thought-provoking book that challenges readers to transcend conventional definitions of freedom and authority. Its relevance to legal studies lies in its exploration of the nature of human consciousness and the limitations of institutional structures.

This review recommends The First and Last Freedom to legal scholars, students, and practitioners seeking a fresh perspective on the intersections of freedom, ethics, and law. By questioning the foundations of societal norms and legal structures, Krishnamurti’s work encourages a broader, more introspective approach to understanding and practising law.

Important Links

Law Library: Notes and Study Material for LLB, LLM, Judiciary, and Entrance Exams

Law Aspirants: Ultimate Test Prep Destination